The Los Angeles Dodgers have long been a powerhouse in Major League Baseball (MLB), boasting a roster filled with some of the game’s brightest talents and future Hall of Famers. Yet, as with any team, the question arises each season: Do we still believe in certain players? Are some stars past their prime, or simply in a slump? Are younger talents ready to step up and carry the legacy forward? And which veterans still have plenty left to give?
This debate is at the heart of every Dodgers fan’s offseason and midseason discussions, especially given the high expectations surrounding this franchise. In this article, we’ll dive deep into the players who have recently been under the microscope. We’ll assess their recent performances, potential, and whether or not they still deserve our faith and confidence going forward.
Setting the Stage: Dodgers Expectations and Pressure
Before we jump into individual players, it’s essential to understand the context. The Dodgers, fresh off multiple postseason appearances and an MLB-best reputation for talent development, are not a team that comfortably accepts mediocrity.
Their front office, led by Andrew Friedman, has repeatedly demonstrated a willingness to pivot and adapt, whether that means trading veterans, giving rookies a shot, or doubling down on their superstar core. For fans, this means patience is a limited commodity. If a player isn’t producing, speculation grows quickly.
1. Corey Seager: The Face of Resurgence or Question Mark?
The Background
Corey Seager’s journey with the Dodgers has been a rollercoaster. A key part of the 2020 World Series championship squad, Seager left in free agency to join the Texas Rangers but recently returned to LA. Known for his clutch hitting and smooth defensive play at shortstop, Seager was once considered a cornerstone.
Recent Performance
Injuries, inconsistent at-bats, and adjusting to new pitching have muddled his recent seasons. His power numbers have dipped, and his batting average is hovering around a mediocre mark for his standards.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: When healthy and locked in, Seager can be a game-changer. His track record of postseason success and leadership is invaluable.
- No, because: Age and injuries have sapped his explosiveness, and the Dodgers have a crowded infield looking to take over.
Verdict:
Seager still has the talent, but the Dodgers need more consistency from him. His value may shift towards a veteran presence rather than a star-level contributor.
2. Mookie Betts: Superstar or Overrated?
The Background
Mookie Betts came to the Dodgers in a blockbuster trade and quickly established himself as a marquee player. His combination of speed, defense, and power makes him one of the most versatile players in the game.
Recent Performance
Betts continues to put up impressive numbers, but some critics say he’s not quite reaching the MVP-caliber levels he once was. His strikeout rate has increased, and while his defensive metrics remain elite, his offensive output has seen slight fluctuations.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: Betts is still among the best five-tool players in baseball, capable of changing the outcome of games defensively and offensively.
- No, because: His contract is massive, and some believe his best years might be behind him, especially given his injury history.
Verdict:
Betts remains a cornerstone. The Dodgers can and should continue to build around him, but monitoring his health and production will be key.
3. Will Smith (Catcher): Emerging Star or Just Average?
The Background
Will Smith is a young catcher who has shown flashes of brilliance both behind the plate and at bat. Catching is a demanding position, and Smith’s ability to manage pitchers has earned him praise.
Recent Performance
Smith’s offensive numbers have been solid but not spectacular, with some inconsistency at the plate. His defense, however, is generally regarded as excellent, especially in pitch framing and controlling the running game.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: Catchers mature with experience, and Smith’s defensive skills make him an essential piece.
- No, because: His offense needs to improve to justify his role as the starting catcher on a championship-level team.
Verdict:
The Dodgers should continue to invest in Smith’s development. He has the tools, and patience is warranted.
4. Gavin Lux: The Future or a Bust?
The Background
Once a highly touted prospect, Gavin Lux has struggled to establish himself as a consistent offensive threat. Injuries and slumps have slowed his development.
Recent Performance
Lux’s batting average and power output have not met expectations, leading some to question if he can ever become the star many hoped he would.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: Lux is young and still adjusting to major league pitching. His athleticism and upside remain intriguing.
- No, because: The Dodgers have other options, and patience might be wearing thin given his prolonged struggles.
Verdict:
Lux is at a crossroads. The next season or two will be pivotal in determining if he can fulfill his potential or become a cautionary tale.
5. Justin Turner: Veteran Leadership or Declining Asset?
The Background
Justin Turner has been a fan favorite for years, known for clutch hitting and veteran savvy. However, age and injuries are catching up.
Recent Performance
Turner’s power and average have declined. His defense at third base has become less reliable, and his playing time has been reduced.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: Turner’s leadership and experience in the clubhouse are invaluable.
- No, because: On-field contributions are diminishing, and younger players may provide more value.
Verdict:
Turner’s role will likely shift towards mentoring and spot starts rather than being an everyday player.
6. Max Muncy: Power Hitter or Liability?
The Background
Muncy has been a critical part of the Dodgers’ lineup, providing power and RBI production. His plate discipline is among the best in the league.
Recent Performance
Muncy’s power numbers have been consistent, but his batting average has dipped slightly. His defense remains solid at first base.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: Muncy’s ability to drive in runs and get on base is crucial for the Dodgers’ offense.
- No, because: His streakiness at the plate and defensive limitations could be a concern.
Verdict:
Muncy remains a key player, though some minor regression could be expected.
7. Julio Urías: Ace or Questionable Durability?
The Background
Urías emerged as a frontline starter and postseason hero for the Dodgers. His unique pitching style, mixing deception and control, has baffled hitters.
Recent Performance
Durability has been a question, with periodic injuries interrupting his rhythm. When healthy, he’s a top-of-the-rotation talent.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: His stuff and command make him an ace-caliber pitcher.
- No, because: The Dodgers’ rotation depth might force them to consider more reliable options if health issues persist.
Verdict:
Urías is a must-believe player, but the Dodgers need a contingency plan.
8. Tony Gonsolin: Reliable or Inconsistent?
The Background
Gonsolin has provided solid innings in both starting and bullpen roles. He’s versatile and effective when on.
Recent Performance
His performance has fluctuated, with some stretches of dominance and some where he struggled to find consistency.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: His adaptability and potential as a swingman are valuable.
- No, because: Inconsistency could limit his role moving forward.
Verdict:
Gonsolin is a useful depth piece, but not a guaranteed difference-maker.
9. The Bullpen: Strength or Weakness?
The Background
The Dodgers’ bullpen has been one of the most scrutinized units in recent years. Starters often get the spotlight, but late-inning arms win games.
Recent Performance
Some key relievers have struggled, leading to blown saves and lost leads in critical moments.
The Debate: Do You Still Believe?
- Yes, because: The Dodgers have a strong track record of acquiring and developing effective relievers.
- No, because: Recent bullpen collapses have cost the team games and momentum.
Verdict:
The bullpen remains a work in progress. Trust is there, but results will dictate belief.
Final Thoughts: Dodgers Fans, It’s a Mixed Bag
Baseball, especially for a high-profile team like the Dodgers, is a constant ebb and flow of hope and doubt. Certain players, like Mookie Betts and Julio Urías, clearly remain pillars of faith. Others, like Gavin Lux and Justin Turner, find themselves in a more uncertain place.
The good news? The Dodgers organization has shown resilience and adaptability in navigating these challenges. New prospects are always on the horizon, and the team’s culture of winning rarely allows prolonged slumps without reaction.
So, do you believe in these Dodger players still?
The answer depends on who you ask, but what remains clear is that belief in baseball — and in the Dodgers — is a dynamic, evolving debate.
